Split Between Woke Right and Trump Loyalists

A growing ideological divide within conservative circles has emerged as prominent right-wing personalities clash over what critics call the “woke right”—a faction accused of adopting identity politics and grievance-based thinking traditionally associated with progressive movements.

The schism has pitted established conservative voices like Jordan Peterson and Ben Shapiro against newer influencers, creating fractures in the MAGA coalition that could impact Republican unity during Trump’s second term.

Top Lists & Life Hacks You’ll Wish You Saw Sooner

Defining the Woke Right Phenomenon

The term “woke right” describes conservatives who critics argue have adopted tactics and mindsets reminiscent of progressive activism, including aggressive online campaigns, identity-based grievance politics, and attempts to silence opposing voices. According to Deseret News, the phenomenon has sparked heated debates among previously allied conservative figures.

James Lindsay, who gained prominence exposing academic “woke” ideology, now argues that segments of the right have embraced similar patterns of behavior. He describes witnessing the same systematic oppression narratives and in-group policing tactics that characterized leftist movements during his earlier activism.

High-Profile Conservative Conflicts

Recent confrontations between major conservative influencers have highlighted the growing divide. Tucker Carlson, Candace Owens, Jordan Peterson, and Ben Shapiro—previously united in supporting Trump—have engaged in public disputes over issues ranging from Israel policy to acceptable discourse tactics within conservative media.

The conflicts have extended beyond policy disagreements to questions about platform responsibilities and the boundaries of acceptable commentary. Some independent media personalities, including Matt Walsh, Tim Pool, and Jack Posobiec, have framed the disputes as establishment attempts to control conservative messaging.

Identity Politics on the Right

Critics of the “woke right” argue that certain conservative factions have begun emphasizing white identity and grievance in ways that mirror progressive identity politics. This includes claims about systematic oppression of conservative white males and the development of victim narratives traditionally associated with leftist movements.

According to The American Conservative, the phenomenon represents a concerning departure from traditional conservative principles that emphasized individual responsibility over group identity. Some observers worry this shift could alienate mainstream voters and undermine conservative electoral prospects.

Online Behavior and Cancel Culture

The “woke right” controversy has also focused attention on social media behavior within conservative circles. Critics point to coordinated harassment campaigns, efforts to “cancel” ideological opponents, and the creation of echo chambers that discourage dissenting viewpoints.

These tactics represent a departure from traditional conservative values of free speech and open debate, instead adopting strategies previously criticized when employed by progressive activists. The development has created tension between classical liberals and newer conservative movements that prioritize cultural warfare over policy discussions.

Intellectual Conservative Pushback

Established conservative intellectuals have pushed back against what they see as the adoption of postmodernist thinking patterns, regardless of political affiliation. They argue that reducing complex issues to power struggles between oppressor and oppressed groups represents a fundamental misunderstanding of conservative principles.

Paul Gottfried, a veteran conservative thinker, has expressed concern about the direction of right-wing discourse while acknowledging the need for some intellectual boundaries. According to Patheos, he supports creating “filters” to prevent the spread of conspiracy theories and racial extremism within conservative movements.

Impact on Republican Politics

The ideological fractures within conservatism could have significant implications for Republican electoral strategy and policy priorities. The disputes highlight fundamental disagreements about the future direction of the conservative movement and its relationship with Trump’s populist agenda.

Some analysts worry that internal conflicts could weaken Republican messaging effectiveness and create opportunities for Democratic opponents to exploit conservative disunity. The debates also reflect broader questions about the sustainability of coalition politics in an increasingly polarized environment.

Looking Forward

The “woke right” phenomenon illustrates the complex challenges facing conservative movements as they navigate cultural and political changes. Traditional conservative institutions must balance maintaining ideological coherence with accommodating diverse viewpoints and new media personalities.

The resolution of these tensions could determine whether the conservative movement maintains intellectual rigor and broad appeal or fragments into competing factions with narrower but more intense followings. The outcome will likely influence Republican political prospects and the broader trajectory of American conservatism.

Trending Tips & Lists You’ll Kick Yourself for Missing