Five Years Later: Hybrid Work Rules Corporate America

Five years after COVID-19 forced a global experiment in remote work, American workplaces have settled into a new rhythm that looks dramatically different from pre-pandemic norms. Despite growing pressure from corporate leaders to return to offices, employees in remote-friendly jobs continue to work from home nearly half the time, highlighting an ongoing tension between employer mandates and worker preferences.

According to research tracking remote employment, employees in remote-friendly positions now spend an average of 2.3 days each week working from home, as reported by The Conversation. When considering all workers, remote work accounts for 28% of paid workdays — a fourfold increase from the 7% recorded in 2019.

Corporate Return-to-Office Momentum

Major employers including Amazon, Dell, Walmart, and federal government agencies have recently strengthened their stance against remote work, requiring select employees to return to offices five days a week. This reverses the flexible work arrangements many companies enthusiastically embraced in 2020.

“One reason bosses want employees back in offices is to make use of expensive corporate real estate,” explains Kory Kantenga, LinkedIn’s head of Americas economist, in an interview with CNBC. “Some leaders may choose to default to how work has been done in the past and think that workers are possibly more productive in the office. Productivity translates to profits.”

A 2024 study of S&P 500 firms found companies were more likely to mandate returns to office after their stock prices declined, hoping that in-person work would boost productivity and improve financial performance. The research also revealed that “return-to-office mandates are more likely in firms with male and powerful CEOs,” according to Mark Ma, an associate business professor at the University of Pittsburgh who led the study.

Five years after COVID, many companies have brought back return-to-office mandates. But if you thrive working from home and want true flexibility, check out these remote-first companies that have fully embraced the work from anywhere model. pic.twitter.com/u72lx0Emm5

— MyJobma – Portfolio Maker (@myjobma_pfolio) March 24, 2025

Employees Resist Full-Time Office Return

Despite the growing corporate push, workers have demonstrated considerable resistance to abandoning remote flexibility. Nearly half of employees who work remotely at least some of the time say they would be unlikely to stay at their job if required to return to the office full-time, according to data from BambooHR.

This resistance is reflected in job search patterns: while only 20% of LinkedIn postings are for remote or hybrid positions, these opportunities receive a disproportionate 60% of applications on the platform, indicating strong worker preference for flexibility.

Some employees who do return to offices may engage in “coffee badging” — making brief appearances before leaving — or demonstrate reduced engagement, which can negatively impact productivity and performance.

Hybrid Models Gain Traction

As the workplace landscape evolves, hybrid arrangements have emerged as the dominant model. According to Flex Index, which tracks workplace strategies of over 10,000 U.S. companies, the percentage of employers requiring daily office attendance fell from 49% in early 2023 to just 32% by the end of 2024.

Simultaneously, fully remote work has declined slightly, from 31% of employers in 2023 to 25% by late 2024. Hybrid work arrangements have filled the gap, growing from 20% of professional workplaces in early 2023 to 43% two years later.

“The story of remote work is more complicated than general trends indicate,” notes The Conversation, with adoption varying significantly by industry, location, and company size. Technology, insurance, telecommunications, professional services, and media companies lead in remote and hybrid arrangements, while states like Massachusetts, Washington, and California show the highest adoption rates.

Five years after COVID accelerated the remote work revolution, its effect on the air is clear. https://t.co/tb5x3QW8oa

— Mashable (@mashable) March 24, 2025

Preference Mismatch

A notable tension exists between employer and employee preferences regarding work arrangements. According to research by Zoom, roughly 25% of professional employees prefer office work, 35% prefer remote work, and 40% prefer hybrid models. Even recent college graduates show diverse preferences, with 15% favoring office work, 20% preferring remote arrangements, and 65% desiring hybrid schedules.

However, disagreement persists over the ideal balance. “While employees favor three days at home and two in the office, employers prefer the opposite: three days in the office and two working remotely,” the Zoom survey found.

Economic and Social Impacts

The shift to remote and hybrid work carries broader economic implications. Clinton Stamper, a 29-year-old Amazon software engineer in Austin, told CNBC he welcomes more in-office time: “You can have small conversations in an elevator. You can randomly run into leadership and do an elevator pitch of your idea.” For him, the office environment helps maintain focus and improves collaboration.

Office attendance also impacts local economies. “Food trucks, laundry services — there are a lot of businesses that depend on workers in the office,” Kantenga notes. “And when workers are not in the office, these businesses don’t do well.”

Looking Forward

Despite intensifying return-to-office mandates, experts believe the hybrid model is here to stay. Most companies with remote and hybrid policies don’t intend to change them in the next 12 months, according to survey findings from Stanford and the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta.

Demographic shifts may also favor flexibility in the long term. “The population is aging, and our workforce is set to shrink,” Kantenga explains. “As that shrinks, employers are going to have to do more to attract employees, and offering flexible work might be the thing that they have to do.”

Sam Spurlin, who advises companies on workplace strategies, offers a cautionary note about viewing office returns as a panacea: “There’s a lot of people talking about RTO as a very simple answer for fixing a lot of very complicated and complex problems within organizations. But if we think we’re going to kind of wave the magic RTO wand and fix some really fundamental problems in our organizations, we’re going to be pretty disappointed.”